Eterniseed › Curriculum › John
John 4 — with Whedon
Opening
In the spirit of Wesleyan inquiry and Arminian confidence in prevenient grace, we turn today to Daniel D. Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments for illumination upon the fourth chapter of John's Gospel. This venerable Methodist scholar guides the reader through sacred narrative with reverent precision, highlighting the Lord's movement from Judea into Samaria and the unfolding revelation at Jacob's well. His exposition invites us to trace divine condescension and the universal offer of living water.
Read
Let us now read the entire fourth chapter of the Gospel according to John, attending to the Lord's journey through Samaria, his conversation with the woman at the well, and the subsequent witness that leads many to believe. May the Spirit quicken our hearts as the sacred text is proclaimed.
Study
Whedon opens by comparing the discourse with Nicodemus to the conversation with the woman of Samaria.
Verses 7-26. Conversation of Jesus with the woman of Samaria, John 4:7-26 . Upon this memorable narrative we may remark: 1. It stands in striking comparison with the Lord’s discourse with Nicodemus. The one was indeed with a leading metropolitan Doctor of the Jews, the latter with a poor country woman, and a Samaritan at that. The former shows our Lord’s dealing with, and mastery over, and development of, the higher minds of the day, in bringing them from their proud half-scepticism to the deepest and most humbling heart-truths of his Gospel. The latter shows how he would take a rude mind of humble rank, and raise it to a knowledge of himself, and in himself to a grasp of the sublimest truths of eternity and God. 2. Modern rationalists have expressed much contempt at the want of dignity of Jesus’s holding this converse with a garrulous female at a country well. Still greater was the contempt of the Jewish rabbis for woman.He next traces the successive steps by which the Lord reveals himself to her.
The successive steps by which the Lord reveals himself furnish a beautiful study into the operations of mind. He presents himself first as a man and a Jew, 7-9; he proposes himself to her faith as a spiritual life-giver, 10-15; he confirms the faith in his offer by proving himself a holy prophet, 16-19; he so unfolds the truths of God as to be accepted as Messias, 20-26. Through all this progress he carries also the thought of her sin and his salvation.On the question of true worship he notes the decisive transition beyond locality.
Verse 20. 20 . Our fathers worshipped It is a great mistake to suppose that she now, by “a womanly dexterity,” changes the discussion to avoid a disagreeable topic. Thou art a prophet, are her thoughts; and if a prophet truly sent from God, thou canst solve this great question between Moriah and Gerizim, of which I, with all Samaritans, have heard from our childhood up. Is salvation of the Jews or of the Samaritans? No expression of deep penitent emotion is indeed recorded; but her testimony in John 4:29 , and her intense action, 28-30, are full proof that the words of this verse are an earnest inquiry, Is salvation from Samaria or from the Jews ? In this mountain Pointing doubtless to Gerizim, rising in grandeur before them, and crowned with its ancient temple. Ye say Here is then the great debate between Our fathers and Ye say; between this mountain and Jerusalem. But if even in this age, when prophecy has long ceased, a true prophet has appeared, then we may get at last some light. Jesus will show her (next verse) that the great debate is coming to an end. Neither Gerizim nor Moriah is the place.
Consider
Whedon presses the explicit declaration of Messiahship made in Samaria.
Verse 26. 26 . I… am he The all-important point is now attained: Jesus has announced himself as Jew, prophet, MESSIAH. No words from her of acknowledgment or surprise are recorded; but how full her faith that the Teacher had arrived who can tell us all things, her energetic and successful mission to her countrymen shows. As the Samaritans did not, in a spirit of national ambition, expect a Messiah of a political character as did the Jews, it was both easier for Jesus on the present occasion to adjust his character to their expectations, and safer from awakening political jealousies, for him with perfect explicitness to avow his own true character and title. The reasons for reserve existing in Judea or Galilee, existed not here in the centre of Samaria. As the time of Jesus in Samaria was short, it was necessary when he found this hearing to reveal himself explicitly and briefly. The more so at this moment, as his disciples were close at hand to cut the opportunity short. These views explain the wonderful fact, that Christ so early and so clearly declared himself to Samaria!He concludes with the recognition of Jesus as the Saviour of the world.
Verse 42. 42 . We have heard… and know A preparatory faith comes by testimony, the fullness of faith by experience. These Samaritans did wisely; first they heard the truth, and then they tried it in practice. Taste and see that the Lord is good. The Saviour of the world A sublime title, indicating that Jesus not only showed that Jew, Samaritan, and Gentile would come into one common dispensation of the Spirit, but that all alike could be saved by the Saviour and by the salvation that is from the Jews. Was this beautiful commencement a failure? Did no future church exist in Samaria? Our Saviour did, indeed, for the same reasons as induced him (see note on Matthew 10:5 ) to direct his apostles to avoid (not the way, but) the cities of the Samaritans, pass rapidly on to Galilee. But the wayside seed was, perhaps, not lost. We find that the apostles had rare success there; the harvest, perhaps, of this wonderful sowing. Acts 8:5-25 . In this town of Sichem arose Justin Martyr, one of the greatest Christian writers of the second century. Samaria became early the seat of an episcopate.
Respond
How does the Lord's willingness to engage the woman at the well challenge our own hesitations in witness? In what ways does Whedon's emphasis on successive revelation invite us to trust the Spirit's patient work in others? Where might we, like the Samaritans, move from testimony to personal experience of the living water?
Pray
Gracious Father, we thank thee for the faithful labors of Daniel D. Whedon and for the light his commentary sheds upon thy holy Word. Grant us, like the woman of Samaria, ears to hear thy Son's voice and hearts to receive the living water he alone supplies. May our witness be bold and our faith experiential, that many may come to know Jesus as Messiah and Saviour of the world. Through Christ our Lord, Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →