Eterniseed › Curriculum › 1 Corinthians
1 Corinthians 8 — with Hodge
Opening
In the spirit of the Reformed tradition, we turn today to Charles Hodge's Commentary on Romans, 1 Corinthians, and Ephesians. Hodge's careful exegesis of 1 Corinthians 8 guides the church in discerning the proper use of Christian liberty, always measured by love for the brethren and fidelity to the one true God. His treatment reminds us that doctrinal clarity must be joined to charity, lest knowledge become a stumbling block rather than a means of edification. We approach this portion of Scripture with reverence, asking the Spirit to apply Hodge's insights to our own consciences and conduct.
Read
Let us now give reverent attention to the eighth chapter of Paul's first epistle to the Corinthians. In these verses the apostle addresses questions concerning meat offered to idols, distinguishing between what is lawful in itself and what is loving toward weaker brothers. Prepare your heart to receive both the doctrinal principles and the practical exhortations contained in this portion of God's Word.
Study
Hodge opens the discussion by placing the Corinthian question within its historical and ecclesiastical setting.
Verse 1. Chapter VIII Eating of sacrifices offered to idols is not in itself wrong, 1 Corinthians 8:1-7 . But it should be avoided if it gave offense, 1 Corinthians 8:8-13 . On Eating of Sacrifices — 1 Corinthians 8:1-13 The second subject on which the Corinthians had requested the advice of the apostle was the lawfulness of eating of the sacrifices offered to idols. To the discussion of that question in its different aspects the eighth, ninth and tenth chapters of this epistle are principally devoted. At the council of Jerusalem it was decided by the apostles, elders and brethren, that the Gentile converts should abstain “from meat offered to idols, from blood, and from things strangled, and from fornication,” Acts 15:29 ; and this decree was referred to the Holy Ghost as its author, Acts 15:28 . Yet Paul, though present in that council, not only does not refer to it, but goes directly against it.Hodge next distinguishes the two aspects under which the apostle views the eating of idol sacrifices.
The decisions of that council, therefore, were no barrier to Paul’s discussing the question on its merits. In this chapter the subject is viewed in two aspects; first, considered in itself; and secondly, in its bearing on the weaker or less enlightened class of Christians. Most of the questions which disturbed the early church had their origin in the conflicting prepossessions and prejudices of the Jewish and Gentile converts; or at least, of the more and less enlightened of the Christian converts. For it is probable that many of those who had been educated as heathen belonged to the class of weaker brethren. As a body, however, the Gentiles were disposed to latitudinarianism; and the Jews to superstitious scrupulousness. So far as general principles were concerned, Paul sided with the Gentile party.Hodge then shows how Paul qualifies the Corinthians' claim to knowledge.
Their views about meats and drinks, and holy days, and ceremonies were derived from the apostle himself, and were therefore approved by him. But the spirit and practice of this party he severely condemns. Thus, in the present instance, he admits that an idol is nothing; that a sacrifice is nothing; that all enlightened Christians know this; that, consequently, eating of the heathen sacrifices was a matter of indifference, it made a man neither better nor worse; and yet eating of them might be, and in their case it was, sinful; because injurious to their weaker brethren. He begins the chapter with the admission, therefore, that all enlightened Christians have knowledge. He reminds them, however, that there is something higher than knowledge; that knowledge without love is, after all, only another form of ignorance. The main thing to be known is not apprehended, 1 Corinthians 10:1-3 .Hodge proceeds to expound the distinction between theoretical and practical knowledge.
In 1 Corinthians 8:1 he may intend himself and his followers. We all , that is, all the stronger or more enlightened class of believers. Whereas, in 1 Corinthians 8:7 , he may refer to Christians generally, including the strong and weak. ‘This knowledge is not in all, for the weak have it not.’ Or the distinction may be between theoretical and practical knowledge. All Christians admit, as a matter of theory, that an idol is nothing, but this knowledge is not in all believers practical and controlling. This also is natural and satisfactory. It is analogous to the statements of this same apostle in reference to the heathen. In Romans 1:23 he says, ‘They know God,’ but in 1 Corinthians 1:21 he says, they ‘know not God.’ These statements are perfectly consistent, because the word know has different senses.
Consider
Hodge presses the inseparable relation between love and true knowledge of God.
Verse 3. 1 Corinthians 8:3 But if any man love God, the same is known of him. To love is to know and to be known. Compare 1 John 4:7 , 1 John 4:8 “Every one that loveth is born of God, and knoweth God; he that loveth not, knoweth not God, for God is love.” This is the precise sentiment of the text. Love is essential to knowledge. He that loves God, knows God. The apostle in this connection interchanges love of the brethren and the love of God, because the love of the brethren is only one of the forms in which the love of God manifests itself. When he said, “Love edifieth,” he meant love to the brethren, and without that love, he says, there can be no true knowledge; but if a man love God, (which includes love to the brethren,) the same is known of him . What is meant by this last expression, is not easy to determine. To be known of God may, according to scriptural usage, mean, 1.Hodge concludes the section by affirming the one God and one Lord revealed in Scripture.
Verse 6. 1 Corinthians 8:6 But to us (there is but) one God, the Father, of whom (are) all things, and we in him; and one Lord Jesus Christ, by whom (are) all things, and we by him. Though there are many creatures called gods, there is but one true God, the creator of all things. To us , i.e. to Christians. There is one God , i.e. only one being who is eternal, self-existing and almighty. This one God is, first, the Father; not the first person of the Trinity, but our father. The word does not here express the relation of the first to the second person in the Godhead, but the relation of God as such to us as his children. When we say, “Our Father who art in heaven,” the word Father designates the Supreme Being, the Triune Jehovah. Secondly, of this one God it is said, of him are all things . He, the one God, is the source of the whole universe, and all that it contains. He created all things by the word of his power.
Respond
How does the priority of love over mere knowledge shape the way you exercise Christian liberty in your daily life? In what areas might your own convictions need to be examined lest they become a stumbling block to weaker brethren? What steps can you take this week to ensure that your knowledge is joined to genuine love for both God and neighbor?
Pray
O Father, who art the one God, and our Lord Jesus Christ the one Lord by whose death the weak are redeemed, grant us Thy Spirit that knowledge may be ruled by love, lest we wound the consciences of those for whom Thy Son died. Strengthen us to walk in Thy covenant grace, denying ourselves for the brethren, that all may redound to the glory of Thy sovereign name. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →