Eterniseed › Curriculum › Ecclesiastes
Ecclesiastes 9-10 — with Whedon
Opening
In the Wesleyan spirit of honest inquiry joined to holy living, we open Daniel D. Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments upon Ecclesiastes chapters nine and ten. Brother Whedon guides us through the Preacher's searching questions with forthright Arminian clarity, refusing to evade the mystery of death's impartiality while pointing always toward the grace that renews the fool. May the same Spirit who inspired these ancient words quicken our minds and order our steps today.
Read
With hearts ready to receive both warning and comfort, let us now read Ecclesiastes chapters nine and ten. Listen prayerfully for the Preacher's candid voice as he weighs life, death, wisdom, and folly under the sun, and ask the Lord to grant us discernment for the living of these days.
Study
Whedon opens the section with:
Introduction. The liability of all men, good and bad, to the common lot, is now stated and illustrated.He then turns to chapter ten with:
Introduction. The relation of wisdom and folly is now discussed, and illustrated in the light of many instances.He presses the matter further by:
Verse 15. 15 . Labour of the foolish wearieth Not merely the talk, but the acts of the fool. These all work to his injury. Even the ordinary affairs of life are more than he can do well, much more politic and discreet behaviour under a despotic ruler. A road to town is sure to be plain and well beaten, and so are common duties clear and well defined, but some people will blunder in both. In dismissing now the character of the fool, of which this book has said so much, it may be said that the amount of space allowed to it in this brief essay is justified by the sad frequency of the character itself. “There be,” says Carlyle, “twenty-seven millions of people in these islands, [Great Britain and Ireland,] most of them Fools.” The fool with Koheleth is not so much lacking in intellect as full of moral perversity. For this the cure revealed is the grace of the Great Physician. This grace, affecting the heart, renovates by degrees the whole nature, and the fool becomes a new man in Christ.
Consider
Finally Whedon weighs the historical setting with:
Verse 20. 20 . Curse not the king Having said in rebuke of the tyrant all that is prudent, admonition of prudence is again given to the subject. It has been remarked that the lack in Hebrew of the little words called particles causes even connected discourse to appear isolated, as if made of separate and distinct propositions. A translation into English or any modern tongue requires the insertion of these. Thus this verse needs to be introduced with Yet, Still, or However. Rich , should be the prince. Reference is here made to the system of espionage which largely prevailed under eastern governments. It was so close and manifold that the figures employed in this verse are not too forcible to express its adroitness and circumstantiality. As the general subject of discreet behaviour in the trying times produced by bad rulers occupies so large a proportion of this brief book, we may, on dismissing it, again say that its moral weight as against the Solomonic authorship is very serious. The books of Scripture, though written for all time, got their special form and matter from and for some particular time. So much of exhortation to patient endurance under misgovernment could not possibly have been inspired by any thing known to have existed in the golden age of Solomon. But there was hardly a year in the interval between 450 B.C. and 330 B.C. when such wisdom of the serpent and harmlessness of the dove was not wanted in almost every province of the Persian empire.
Respond
1. Where in my daily walk do I most need the living hope Whedon highlights? 2. How does the grace that makes the fool a new man invite fresh obedience today? 3. In what present circumstance am I called to patient, prudent faithfulness under trial?
Pray
Gracious God, Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, we thank Thee for the faithful labors of Thy servant Daniel Whedon. Grant us, by Thy sanctifying Spirit, the wisdom to number our days aright and the courage to use our strength while it is day. Where folly has marred our witness, apply again the healing grace of the Great Physician. Keep us loyal in troublous times, patient under rulers, and joyful in the mercies Thou dost daily bestow. Through Christ our Lord. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →