← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › 1 John

1 John 1 — with Haydock's Catholic Commentary

1 John 1Haydock Bible Commentary20 min
Opening
Welcome to this daily lesson drawn from Haydock's Catholic Commentary on the First Letter of John. In these sacred pages the beloved disciple unveils the light of the Word made flesh and calls every heart into communion with the Father. Haydock gathers the wisdom of the Church Fathers to guard the mystery of the Incarnation against ancient errors and to kindle charity in those who read. As we open this chapter together, may the eternal life that was with the Father become manifest in our own hearing and touching of the word of life. Let the commentary guide us into deeper fellowship with the apostles and with one another.
Read
Take the text of 1 John chapter 1 into your hands and read it slowly, allowing each verse to echo in silence. Notice how the apostle begins with what was from the beginning and moves to the fellowship we are invited to share. Read once for the sound of the words, then again for the light they shed on sin and forgiveness. Let the passage rest in your heart before we turn to Haydock's Catholic Commentary for further insight.
Study
Haydock opens by establishing the canonical authority and purpose of the epistle. This epistle was always acknowledged for canonical, and written by St. John, the apostle and evangelist. At what time and place, is uncertain. It is sometimes called the Epistle to the Parthians, or Persians. The chief design is to set forth the mystery of Christ's incarnation against Cerinthus, who denied Christ's divinity, and against Basilides, who denied that Christ had a true body; with zealous exhortations to love God and our neighbour. (Witham) --- The vein of divine love and charity towards our neighbour which runs throughout the gospel written by the beloved disciple and evangelist, St. John, is found also in his epistles. He confirms the two principal mysteries of our faith: the mystery of the Trinity, the mystery of the incarnation of Jesus Christ, the Son of God. The sublimity and excellence of the evangelical doctrine he declares: "And this commandment we have from God, that he who loveth God love also his brother;" (Chap. iv. 21.) and again, "For this is the charity of God, that we keep his commandments; and his commandments are not heavy." (Chap. v. 3.) He shews how to distinguish the children of God from those of the devil; marks out those who should be called antichrists; describes the turpitude and gravity of sin. Finally, he shews how the sinner may hope for pardon. It was written, according to Baronius's account, sixty-six years after our Lord's ascension. (Challoner) --- The effect of all is to prove the certainty of the Catholic faith, and to renounce all heretics and schismatics, who entice persons from the true saving faith. He next unfolds the opening verses and their link to the Gospel prologue. 1Jn 1:1 first two verses and part of the third have a great conformity with the beginning of St. John's gospel. The construction is somewhat obscure, unless we observe that the second verse is to be taken by way of a parenthesis, and the sense is not complete till these words, we declare to you, &c. The whole may be expressed in this literal paraphrase: We declare and preach to you the eternal and always living word, which was from the [1] beginning, (for this word which was with the Father from eternity, hath appeared,[2] and manifested himself to us, when he took upon him our human nature, and was made flesh). This word I say, incarnate, we have seen with our eyes, we have heard him preach his gospel, we have touched his true body with our hands, as we witness and declare to you, that you may have fellowship with us, and be made partakers of the graces which God came from heaven to bestow upon mankind, to make us his adoptive sons and heirs of heaven. (Witham) On verse 8 the commentary addresses the claim of being without sin. 1Jn 1:8 that we say or pretend we have no sin;[4] thus truth would not be in us, and we should even make God a liar, who has declared all mankind guilty of sin. We were all born guilty of original sin; we have fallen, and still frequently fall into lesser sins and failings. We can only except from this number our Saviour Christ, who, even as man, never sinned, and his blessed Virgin Mother, by a special privilege, preserved from all kind of sin: and of whom St. Augustine[5] says, "that for the honour of our Lord, when we speak of the holy Virgin Mary, he will have no mention at all made of any sin." (Witham)
Consider
Haydock then connects the text to the corresponding phrases in John's Gospel. Et vita manifesta est. This corresponds to, in ipso vita erat, [in him was life, (John i. 4.)] and apparuit nobis to Verbum Caro Factum est. [the Word was made flesh. (John i. 14)] And it was true to say that they had seen the eternal word, not as God, but under the veil of human nature.
Respond
How does the certainty of the Incarnation reshape the way you speak about your own sins today? In what concrete way can you extend the fellowship the apostle describes to someone outside your usual circle? Where might you be tempted to claim a sinlessness that the commentary warns against?
Pray
Eternal Word who was with the Father from the beginning, we thank you for the testimony handed down through your apostle John. Grant that the light we have heard and seen may keep us from every falsehood and draw us into true fellowship with you and with one another. Preserve us from the ancient errors that still whisper today and fill us with the charity that fulfills every commandment. May the blood of Jesus cleanse us from all sin and make us children of the light. Amen.

Haydock Bible Commentary · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →