Eterniseed › Curriculum › Romans
Romans 9 — with Benson
Opening
Grace and peace attend us as we open Joseph Benson's the Commentary on the Old and New Testaments for a patient walk through Romans chapter 9. In the warm spirit of Wesleyan faith we listen for the apostle's heart and for the steady mercy of God that chooses, calls, and keeps his people. Benson's careful exposition will guide us through tender sorrow, covenant privilege, and the mystery of divine electing love, always pointing us to Christ. May the same Spirit who searched the apostle's conscience search ours, that we receive the word with meekness and rise to serve the Lord with gladness.
Read
With Scripture open before us, let us read Romans chapter 9 slowly and prayerfully. Hear the apostle's solemn oath, his deep grief for Israel, and the unfolding witness that God's word has not failed. As the words are spoken aloud, invite the Holy Spirit to apply every promise and warning to the heart, that faith may be strengthened and love for the church enlarged.
Study
Benson opens by sketching the apostle's tender yet resolute handling of Israel's rejection.
Introduction. A.M. 4064. A.D. 60. The apostle, finding it necessary to speak more expressly of the rejection of the Jews, and the calling of the Gentiles, here introduces the subject; and, (1,) In very tender expressions avows his regard to his Jewish brethren, several of whose great privileges and peculiar advantages he here enumerates, Romans 9:1-5 . And then, (2,) Shows that the rejection of a considerable part of the seed of Abraham, and even of the posterity of Isaac, from the peculiar privileges of God’s chosen people, was an incontestable fact, which the Jews could not but grant to have happened; that is, with regard to the descendants of Ishmael and Esau, Romans 9:6-13 . (3,) That the sovereign choice of some individuals to peculiar privileges, to which none had any claim, and the sovereign appointment, from among many criminals, of some to peculiar and exemplary punishment, was perfectly consistent both with reason and Scripture, Romans 9:14-24 . (4,) That the admission of the Gentiles to the privileges of God’s peculiar people, when Israel should be rejected, was so far from being inconsistent with Scripture, that it had been actually foretold, both by Hosea and Isaiah , vv25-33.Benson next insists that the chapter contains no doctrine of personal election or reprobation.
That the apostle had not here the least thought of personal election or reprobation, is manifest, 1st, Because it lay quite wide of his design, which, as has been just observed, was merely to show that God’s rejecting the Jews, and receiving the Gentiles, was consistent with his word: 2d, Because such a doctrine would not only have had no tendency to convince, but would have evidently tended to harden the Jews: 3d, Because when he sums up his argument, in the close of the chapter, he says not one word, nor gives the least intimation about it. I say the truth in Christ This being a solemn appeal to Christ and the Holy Ghost, as knowing the apostle’s heart, for the truth of what he affirmed, it is of the nature of an oath.Benson then shows that not all physical descendants of Israel are the true Israel of promise.
This sentiment Paul now refutes, showing, 1st, That the word itself had foretold their rejection: and, 2d, That though the body of the nation was rejected, God’s promises were already fulfilled to the true Israelites, and hereafter all Israel should be saved: which is the sum of the ninth, tenth, and eleventh chapters. For Here he enters upon the proof of it; they are not all Israel True spiritual Israelites, to whom the promises belong; which are of Israel The natural posterity of Jacob, and Israelites by birth, and so visible members of the church. The Jews vehemently maintained the contrary; namely, that all who were born Israelites, and they only, were the people of God. The former part of this assertion is refuted here, the latter, Romans 9:24 , &c. The sum is, God accepts all believers, and them only; and this is no way contrary to his word.
Consider
Benson presses the chapter's central intention with clarity and pastoral care.
As it is written With which word in Genesis, spoken so long before, that of Malachi agrees; I have loved Jacob With a peculiar love; that is, the Israelites, the posterity of Jacob; and I have comparatively hated Esau That is, the Edomites, the posterity of Esau. But observe, 1st, This does not relate to the person of Jacob or Esau: 2d, Nor does it relate to the eternal state either of them or their posterity. Thus far the apostle has been proving his proposition, namely, that the exclusion of a great part of the seed of Abraham, yea, and of Isaac, from the special promises of God, was so far from being impossible, that, according to the Scriptures themselves, it had actually happened.Benson concludes by answering the charge of unrighteousness in God's dealings.
Verses 14-16. Romans 9:14-16 . What shall we say then? To this. The apostle now introduces and refutes an objection. Is there unrighteousness, or injustice, with God? In the distribution of his providential blessings, in this or any other instance that can be produced? Was it unjust in God to choose Jacob and his posterity to be the members of his visible church on earth, and to inherit the promises in their literal meaning, rather than Esau and his posterity? Or to accept believers who imitate the faith of Jacob, and them only? God forbid In no wise: this is well consistent with justice. For he saith to Moses, &c. For he has a right to fix the terms on which he will show mercy; according to his declaration to Moses, petitioning for all the people, after they had been guilty of idolatry in worshipping the golden calf; I will have mercy on whom I will have mercy According to the terms I myself have fixed; and I will have compassion on whom I will have compassion Namely, on those only who submit to my terms; who accept of it in the way that I have appointed. So then The inference to be drawn is; It The blessing; therefore is not of him that willeth, nor of him that runneth It is not the effect either of the will or the works of man, but of the grace and power of God. The will of man is here opposed to the grace of God, and man’s running, to the divine operation. And this general declaration respects not only Isaac and Jacob, and the Israelites in the time of Moses, but likewise all the spiritual children of Abraham, even to the end of the world.
Respond
1. Where do I discover the same Spirit-given sorrow for those who have not yet believed? 2. How does the distinction between outward privilege and living faith shape my hope for the church today? 3. In what ways am I learning to rest in the mercy that depends not on human willing or running but on the call of God?
Pray
Gracious God, Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, we thank thee for the faithful witness of thy servant Joseph Benson and for the light his commentary sheds upon thy holy word. Grant us, we beseech thee, the same love for Israel and for all nations that filled the apostle's heart. Keep us from presumption and from despair; teach us to trust thy electing mercy while we labour in prayer and witness. May the privileges of the gospel never be taken for granted among us, but may they lead us daily to deeper faith, purer love, and more joyful obedience. Through Christ our Lord, Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →