Eterniseed › Curriculum › John
John 8 — with Whedon
Opening
In the spirit of Methodist Episcopal inquiry we turn today to Daniel D. Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments for its treatment of John chapter 8. Whedon’s forthright Arminian-Wesleyan exposition illumines both the contested narrative of the woman taken in adultery and the Lord’s majestic self-attestation amid hostile unbelief. His careful weighing of textual evidence and doctrinal implication invites us to receive Scripture with both reverence and honest scrutiny. As we listen, may the same Spirit who guided the evangelist guide our hearts to the Light of the world.
Read
Let us now read the eighth chapter of John in a spirit of attentive devotion, allowing the sacred text to speak before we turn to Whedon’s measured commentary. Pause after each section to let the words of Jesus settle deeply within the conscience and the will.
Study
Whedon opens by weighing the external and internal evidence concerning the authorship of the adulteress narrative.
Verses 2-11. § 82. THE WOMAN TAKEN IN ADULTERY, John 8:2-11 . A majority of the best biblical scholars agree that this narrative of the adulteress, (including John 7:53 ,) though of apostolic antiquity, could scarce have been written by John. The external proofs are: 1. Its absence from a large share of the best manuscripts. 2. The absence of quotations of the passage in the earliest Christian writers. And, 3. The great variety of readings in the different copies of the passage. The internal proofs are: 1. Its unlikeness to the style of John, both in its general tenor and its particular terms. 2. The possibility of removing it from the text without producing any break. 3. Its discordance with the current of thought, so as to form an actual interruption. To the force of these arguments we are obliged to yield. In the entire context there is an open hostility between the Jews and Jesus; but in this passage there is on the contrary a state of pretended friendship and deference. They come with submissive air to receive from him, as authoritative judge, a legal decision, tempting him. This mode of tempting him is precisely of the same cast, and implies the same state of things, as we find in § 115. In some manuscripts, indeed, the passage is found at the end of Luke 21:0 . The most suitable place for it is, perhaps, among the similar attempts at tempting in Mark 12:13-35 . There can be no reasonable doubt of its forming a true part of Gospel history. The only questions are as to its authorship and place.He proceeds to unfold the precise dilemma posed to Jesus and the symbolic action of writing upon the ground.
Verse 6. 6 . Tempting him Putting him to the test. Endeavouring to subject him to a dilemma. The dilemma was this: If he decided the case, he rebelled against the Roman government by taking law into his own hands; if he declined it, he abdicated his claim as Messiah. And still more: if he decided that the Mosaic law should be fulfilled, he would, contrary to Roman decree, inflict capital punishment; if he disregarded Moses, he submitted to Rome, and degraded his Messiahship with all earnest Jews. Stooped down From his sitting posture. Wrote on the ground On the hard pavement of the temple court. The written character, if any, would be in the slight layer of dust. This writing was a sign of purposed inattention to their address. It declared that this was a case with which he had nothing to do. With singular tact it declared this in act, which it would not do to declare in words. What did Jesus write? This question, though discussed by commentators, is very much like asking what did the seven thunders ( Revelation 10:4 ) utter? And yet, when Jesus resumed his writing, in John 8:8 , there seems a solemn significance about it. To the culprit accusers themselves it doubtless seemed that that finger could write their own deeds of darkness, recalled by conscience to their present recollection.Whedon then records the Master’s challenge to the accusers regarding their own sinlessness.
Verse 7. 7 . Continued asking They do not easily take a hint that their room is better than their company. They do, at this moment, doubtless understand that he intimates his rejection of all prerogative in the case. But they mean that no amount of finger-writing shall defeat their purpose. Said unto them Thus doth Judge Messiah decide: The accused is beyond all question worthy of death. Let, then, the low standard of modern degeneracy be at once abolished, and let the pure ideal of Moses’s law be restored in its severest purity. As soon, therefore, as a court, witnesses, and executioners of the true Mosaic standard are furnished, let them execute the absoluteness of the Mosaic sentence by casting the first stone! Without sin That is, without a sin of such enormity as would render him liable to stand in the woman’s place if Mosaic or Messianic law should be applied.
Consider
Whedon concludes the episode by affirming its apostolic antiquity and wise discrimination.
Verse 11. 11 . Neither do I condemn thee Namely, as a legal judge pronouncing a judicial sentence; such as they had required of him. Nor, indeed, as a divine judge; for that office he reserves to his second coming, ( John 8:15 .) Neander says: “He takes the sin out of the domain of earthly judicature, which is foreign to his own divine office, into his own peculiar province of morality.” He deals with her not by human but by divine law. Go As he claimed no municipal authority to detain her. Sin no more Though as a judge Jesus, as having no jurisdiction, could not condemn her, yet, as a preacher of righteousness, he rebukes her of sin, and as a Redeemer points her to repentance and reformation. On the whole, though unable to assign this narrative to the authorship of John, we conclude that in none of the instances of Jewish tempting of Jesus are his replies more delicately discriminating or more transparently wise.He later unveils the satanic paternity of persistent unbelief.
Verse 44. 44 . Your father Not Abraham, not God, but the devil. It is clear that the devil is here named as a personal being, as truly as Abraham or God. Lusts… will do Their sonship consists in the conformity of their lusts and their doings to their father’s. A murderer As these men are in heart murderers of Jesus, John 7:19 ; John 8:28 ; John 8:37 ; John 8:40 . Murderer from the beginning He murdered the previously pure and perfect Adam, and through him murdered the race. Cain was his son and image, showing by his character what his father Satan was. Abode not in the truth In which he once stood, but, as his lie to Eve showed, most disastrously fell. So that as the devil is here most clearly named as a personal being, so his FALL, from his previous purity is decisively implied. No truth in him He is so completely full of lie, that there is no room for truth in him Such are the great mass of wicked men. Satan’s falsehood so completely fills them, that they admit not a particle of the opposite truth of God. He speaketh of his own Speaketh out from the full fund that is in him. Father of it The grand original inventor of all lying in the universe. Before he lied, the harmony of truth universally reigned. God and all were truth; Satan created lie. Others, however, as Alford, render this phrase, Father of him, that is, of the liar. Satan is the liar and the liar’s father. This accords with the current of thought, as Jesus is speaking of moral paternity and sonship.
Respond
1. How does Whedon’s careful handling of textual questions strengthen rather than weaken your confidence in the Gospel record?
2. In what ways does the Lord’s refusal to condemn while still commanding “sin no more” shape your understanding of holy grace?
3. Where do you sense the Spirit inviting you to reject the lies of the evil one and walk as a child of the Light?
Pray
Gracious Father, we thank Thee for the faithful labors of Daniel D. Whedon and for the light his commentary sheds upon Thy holy Word. Grant us the same reverent honesty he displayed, that we may neither add to nor diminish the testimony of Scripture. Cleanse our hearts from every satanic falsehood, and let the true Light of Christ shine within us. May we who have been set free by His truth continue in that freedom, bringing forth fruit worthy of repentance. Through Jesus Christ our Lord, who with Thee and the Holy Spirit liveth and reigneth, one God, world without end. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →