Eterniseed › Curriculum › 1 Corinthians
1 Corinthians 11 — with Whedon
Opening
In the spirit of Methodist Episcopal inquiry and Arminian confidence in Scripture’s plain sense, we turn today to Daniel D. Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments. Whedon’s verse-by-verse exposition of First Corinthians eleven guides the Church through questions of order in worship and fidelity to apostolic example. His treatment blends careful attention to ancient custom with unwavering regard for the permanent principles of modesty, headship, and sacramental reverence. As we open these pages we ask the Spirit to grant us both the cheer of uncovered boldness before God and the humble covering that befits every daughter of the Lord.
Read
Let us now read together the entire eleventh chapter of First Corinthians. Listen for the apostle’s careful distinctions between what is of fixed divine law and what belongs to the fitting expression of modesty in a given age. Receive the word as those who desire both the liberty of the gospel and the beauty of holy order within the household of faith.
Study
Whedon opens by placing the Corinthian question within the varied customs of head attire among Jews, Greeks, and Romans.
Verses 2-16. PAUL’S SIXTH RESPONSE: REGARDING THE HEAD-COSTUME OF THE DIFFERENT SEXES IN RELIGIOUS SERVICES, 1 Corinthians 11:2-16 . Stanley well describes the intense religions significance of modes of dress in ancient times. In earlier Greece the length of the garment decided whether a man was an Ionian, with one set of gods and rites, or a Dorian, with another. But it was in the religious duties that the dress of the head possessed a marked import. The Jews, as Grotius says, were accustomed to perform the services of the temple with the head covered, assigning as a reason for the symbolic act that their unworthy eyes might not behold the majesty of God. This mode of reverence they transferred to the synagogue; so that, following Hebrew custom, St. Paul would have required men as well as women to worship with covered head. The ancient Greeks, on the contrary, sacrificed with bared heads.He next unfolds the scriptural order of headship that undergirds the apostolic directive.
Verse 3. 3 . Head of every man Of every Christian, says Grotius. Yet in the redemption Christ has a headship of the race. See notes on Romans 5:12-21 . Here, however, as a harmonious ruling and obeyed headship is implied, Grotius’s limitation is correct. Of every man , by Paul addressed, the Head was Christ . The headship of our Lord over the Christian man is a headship of divine authority, in which, however, when complete and perfect, the authority merges into a blessed spontaneity and concurrence of wills. Such is the apostle’s view of marriage, of which the union of Christ and his Church is the type. A divinely-constituted headship similarly belongs to the husband in the family; but the true idea of the family is a unity of love, in which the command is the expression of the common happiness, and obedience is a loving concurrence of wills.Whedon then turns to the reports Paul received concerning men who prayed with covered heads.
Verse 4. 4 . Every man praying… covered Either from the Corinthian letter or the messengers that brought it, Paul learned that the Christian rule of worship was unsettled. Men following the Hebrew or Roman custom probably prayed with the head covered. Women, doubting what under the Christian system was the law for their sex, in what they perhaps considered Christian freedom removed the customary hood from their heads. The notion of Ruckart and others, that the motive of these uncovering women was to display their beauty, has not one syllable in the apostle’s rebuke or argument to sustain it. On the contrary, his whole force of reasoning goes to show that a proper subordination truly belongs to the female sex; and it is solely a questioning of this truth which his argument presupposes. It does not appear that any real disorders occurred.He proceeds to examine the case of women who prayed and prophesied in the assembly.
Verse 5. 5 . Every woman that prayeth… prophesieth Grotius thus comments: “So in the Old Testament women were prophetesses, as Miriam, sister of Moses, Exodus 15:20 ; Deborah, Judges 4:1 ; Judges 4:5 ; the wife of Isaiah, Isaiah 8:3 ; Huldah, 2 Kings 22:14 ; so also in the New Testament, the daughters of Philip, Acts 21:9 , and others. Such were accustomed also to expound the sacred prophecies publicly, as appears from the passages above quoted from the Old Testament. Wherefore Paul’s prohibition of women from performing the office of teaching, is to be understood with this exception, unless they have the special commandment of God.” Wetstein says, similarly: “It was not permissible for women to teach or lead prayers in the congregation, (xiv, 34,) unless, for an exceptional reason and in a special manner, they were impelled to so doing by the Spirit of God.
Consider
Whedon presses the conclusion that apostolic authority and churchly custom together settle the matter against contentious innovation.
Verse 16. 16 . Contentious The whole question had, it seems, been a subject of Corinthian debate. Men, perhaps, maintained, that according to Jewish and Roman custom their heads should be uncovered in worship. Women, perhaps, maintained that Christ had emancipated woman from her reserve and subjection. The apostle replaces the law of propriety and of God in their proper authority. Such custom As these mistaken reformers would introduce. Churches The debate, probably, had scarce extended beyond Corinth. At least propriety and apostolic and churchly authority had elsewhere settled the question. The authority of the churches of God in this, the age of the gifted Church, was co-ordinate with the authority of the inspired apostles.He finally directs attention to the disorders that had arisen at the Lord’s Supper itself.
Verses 17-34. PAUL’S SEVENTH RESPONSE: AS TO DISORDERS AT THE LORD’S SUPPER, 1 Corinthians 11:17-34 . The supper of our Lord the night of his betrayal was divisible into three parts: First, the proper passover service, according to the law of Moses; second, an ordinary meal for the natural satiation of hunger, according to custom; and, third, the eucharistic bread and wine which he then first established as a memorial of his death. Of course the first of the three disappeared at the commencement of Christianity, leaving the other two. Of these two the first became the agape, or love-feast; the last remained, forever, the Lord’s supper. In Corinth the agape seems to have been slightly modified by two Grecian customs. One of these customs was the eranos, or symposium; a banquet to which the guests each brought a portion of the food and drink as in our modern picnic. A master of the feast was elected.
Respond
1. In what present-day customs of worship do we still need to distinguish between the unchanging law of God and the fitting expression of modesty?
2. How does the principle of headship shape both the liberty and the ordered beauty of Christian households today?
3. Where might our gatherings at the Lord’s table risk the very divisions Paul so sharply rebuked?
Pray
Gracious Father, we thank thee for the apostolic word preserved for our instruction. Grant us, after the mind of Christ, both the uncovered boldness of sons and the modest covering that honors the order thou hast established. May every assembly of thy people reflect the harmony of headship and love, and may our table fellowship be kept from all pride and partiality. Clothe us with the Spirit of humility, that we may rightly discern the body of thy Son and worthily show forth his death until he come. Through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →