Eterniseed › Curriculum › Jeremiah
Jeremiah 41-42 — with Haydock's Catholic Commentary
Opening
Welcome to this daily lesson drawn from Haydock's Catholic Commentary on Sacred Scripture. In these chapters of Jeremiah we encounter the turbulent aftermath of Jerusalem's fall and the fragile hopes of a remnant seeking divine guidance. Haydock's Catholic Commentary gathers the insights of earlier Catholic exegetes to illuminate the historical and spiritual stakes. As we proceed through the six beats, we will read the biblical text, study selected passages from the commentary, consider key connections, respond in reflection, and conclude in prayer, allowing the Church's ancient wisdom to shape our hearing of God's word today.
Read
Take up the sacred text and read Jeremiah chapters 41 and 42 slowly and prayerfully. Notice the violence that erupts after the governor's assassination and the people's anxious plea for direction from the prophet. Let the narrative unfold without haste, attending to both the human fear and the divine invitation to trust. When you finish, return here ready to study how Haydock's Catholic Commentary unfolds the passage.
Study
Haydock opens by recounting the circumstances of the murder in chapter 41.
Haydock Catholic Bible Commentary Month; Tisri, the third of which is still observed as a fast by the Jews. (Calmet) --- Godolias had given a supper to the traitors, and had drunk plentifully. They set upon him while he and the people were retired to rest. (Josephus, Antiquities x. 11.) --- This happened two months after the burning of Jerusalem, chap. xxix. 2. Nabuchodonosor soon after punished this perfidy of the Ammonites. (Calmet) --- Bread: feasted. (Haydock) --- Such tragedies are usually performed with the show of friendship. (Worthington)The commentary next examines the mourning rites and pilgrimage to Masphath.
Rent, as people mourning. Literally, "dirty." Hebrew and Septuagint, "cut." (Haydock) (Chap. xvi. 6., and Leviticus xix. 28.) --- Lord, Masphath, were people performed their devotions, as well as they could, Judges xx. 1., and 1 Machabees iii. 46.) Jeremias had probably ordered an altar to be erected, as Samuel had done, 1 Kings vii. 6. (Calmet) --- Others think that these people went thither for a priest, to offer what they had brought on the altar of Jerusalem, Baruch i. 10. (Tirinus) --- Masphath lay to the south. (Calmet) --- It seems many of the people about Samaria were true believers, and even more affected at the destruction of the temple. (Haydock) --- Their city had been demolished by Salmanasar (Calmet) long before, and many fresh inhabitants introduced, who adhered to idols. (Haydock)On the request for prophetic guidance in chapter 42, Haydock supplies the initial exchange.
Witness. Jeremias knew their fickle temper. They will obey, only if God comply with their desires. (Calmet) --- They began with piety, but soon refused to obey the directions given, chap. xliii. 2. (Worthington)
Consider
Haydock then clarifies the meaning of seeking an answer good or evil.
Good or evil. That is, agreeable or disagreeable. (Challoner) --- It would have been well for them if they had been sincere, (ver. 10.; Haydock) and determined to comply whether the prophet announced prosperity or the reverse. (Worthington)The commentary concludes by addressing the charge of self-deception.
Deceived. Septuagint, "done ill in your souls." Your intention was bad. You thought that I should speak conformably to your wishes. (Calmet) --- He saw by the prophetic light, or by their deportment, that they were bent on going. (Haydock) --- They were doubly guilty in neither observing their promise nor obeying God's decree. (Worthington)
Respond
How does the remnant's request for counsel challenge my own habits of seeking God's will? In what ways might I be tempted to ask for guidance only when I already expect a favorable reply? Where is the Lord inviting me to remain in the land he has appointed rather than flee to safer-seeming alternatives?
Pray
Lord God of Israel, you continued to speak through your prophet Jeremiah amid the people’s fear and wavering, calling them to seek your will without conditions and to remain where you had placed them. Grant us the grace to accept both your consolation and your correction, and strengthen our fidelity through the intercession of Jeremiah and all the holy prophets when fear urges flight. We ask this through Christ our Lord. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →