Eterniseed › Curriculum › 1 Samuel
1 Samuel 7-8 — with Whedon
Opening
In the quiet strength of Wesleyan conviction we turn today to Daniel D. Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments. Across these pages the veteran Methodist expositor traces the movement of divine providence through Samuel's ministry, the repentance at Mizpeh, and the fateful request for a king. His Arminian clarity reminds us that grace cooperates with obedient hearts while human choices carry lasting consequence. We listen reverently, ready to receive both warning and hope from the same sacred history that shaped early Methodism's trust in Scripture and free response to God.
Read
With hearts prepared by prayer, let us read 1 Samuel chapters 7 and 8. Hear how the Lord answers Samuel's intercession, restores Israel's borders, and then records the people's demand for a king. Read slowly, noting the contrast between humble repentance and the desire to be like the nations. Allow the Spirit to search our own affections as the ancient story unfolds.
Study
Whedon opens the narrative of deliverance by marking the long silence and Samuel's hidden labors.
Verse 2. THE GREAT DELIVERANCE AND REFORM UNDER SAMUEL, 1 Samuel 7:2-17 . 2 . Twenty years A period of silence in the history of Israel. What notable events occurred and what Samuel did during these twenty years are largely matters of conjecture. Some suppose that this period was nearly simultaneous with the twenty years of Samson’s judgeship. Judges 15:20 . This opinion claims no certain proof in the biblical record; only it is probable that the forty years of Philistine oppression ( Judges 13:1 ) from which Samson began to deliver Israel is the same oppression which was completely removed by the instrumentality of Samuel, as recorded in this chapter. Samson’s authority as judge was confined to southwestern Israel, and probably never came in contact with that of either Eli or Samuel. There is nothing at war with the supposition that two or more judges in Israel were contemporary.He next presents Samuel's timely word that turns lament into decisive reform.
Verse 3. 3 . Samuel spake His words of warning and reproof had probably been instrumental in causing the lamentation after the Lord just referred to. Upon their showing proper signs of repentance and humiliation he comes forth to lead them in the great work of reform.Whedon then records the Lord's thunderous answer to the prophet's intercession at Mizpeh.
Verse 10. 10 . The Lord thundered with a great thunder Rather, with a great voice. Thus in Samuel’s day was Hannah’s prophecy fulfilled. 1 Samuel 2:10 . Compare also the marginal references. This amazing miracle was wrought in answer to Samuel’s prayer, and was a confirmation of his words to Israel as recorded in 1 Samuel 7:3 . It showed, too, that the Jehovah of the exodus was still powerful to save his people and confound their enemies.
Consider
Whedon weighs the deeper constitutional questions behind Israel's request for monarchy.
But there were deeper, though more remote, reasons for a modification a revolution even in the form of the Israelitish government. We do not understand that it was the purpose or desire of Jehovah to have his people permanently governed by a class of rulers like the Judges, who had no constitutional authority over all the tribes. These officers, as we have shown in the Introduction to the Book of Judges, were extraordinary ministers, raised up by the special providence of God to meet existing emergencies, but formed no permanent part of the machinery of the Hebrew government as contemplated in the Laws of Moses. The Law prescribed no specific form of government, but was full of suggestive principles, which should have guided the people long before the time of Samuel into the adoption of a constitution that would have secured them national unity.He finally exposes the ingratitude that turned a lawful desire into rejection of the Lord.
Moses had made provision in the Law ( Deuteronomy 17:14-20 ) for the appointment and guidance of a king in Israel, should the people choose to establish a monarchy. So we are not to blame these elders for the choice of a monarchical form of government, for they might have naturally inferred from the ancient prophecies that God intended that a monarchy should rise in Israel. Their sin in asking for a king is to be seen in the spirit of disaffection with which they asked, and their implied reflection on Jehovah’s mercy and care in raising up for them deliverers when they were about to sink under the bitter oppression of foreign powers. It was for this culpable ingratitude, and their tendency to heathenish customs, manifest in the demand for a king like all the nations, that Jehovah, with abundant reason, declared, ( 1 Samuel 8:7 ,) “They have rejected me.”
Respond
1. Where in my life has a season of quiet preparation preceded a clear work of God? 2. How might lingering affection for worldly patterns still grieve the Lord who alone is King? 3. What signs of genuine repentance does the Spirit invite me to bring before Him today?
Pray
Gracious Lord of hosts, who answered Samuel with thunder and restored Thy people, grant us like repentance and like faith. Keep us from every desire to be like the nations around us. Form in us a willing heart under Thy sole kingship, that we may walk in the liberty of Thy Spirit and the obedience of Thy Word. Raise up leaders after Thine own heart, and let Thy hand remain upon Thy church all our days. Through Christ our Lord, Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →